Back to Blog
CAFC-PTOAugust 26, 2026·26-1357·Appeal No. 2026-1357 dismissed; each side bears its own costs; mandate issued as to that appeal only. Appeal No. 2026-1390 remains pending.

Ascend Elements, Inc. v. Duesenfeld GmbH

Patent Trial and Appeal Board

Holding

The Federal Circuit deconsolidated the appeals and voluntarily dismissed Appeal No. 2026-1357 under Rule 42(b). The court did not reach any patent-law merits issue.

Why It Matters

This is a procedural termination of one PTAB appeal only, leaving the related cross-appeal to proceed under the court’s prior scheduling/order requirements.

Full Summary

Ascend Elements, Inc. v. Duesenfeld GmbH The Federal Circuit deconsolidated the appeals and voluntarily dismissed Appeal No. 2026-1357 under Rule 42(b). The court did not reach any patent-law merits issue. This is a procedural termination of one PTAB appeal only, leaving the related cross-appeal to proceed under the court’s prior scheduling/order requirements. Appeal No. 2026-1357 dismissed; each side bears its own costs; mandate issued as to that appeal only. Appeal No. 2026-1390 remains pending. The order is nonprecedential and addresses only voluntary dismissal procedure. The appeal arose from PTAB IPR2024-00948, but the order does not identify the challenged patent, technology, or merits issues. The parties jointly stipulated to dismiss Appeal No. 2026-1357 under FRAP 42(b), with each side bearing its own costs. The Federal Circuit deconsolidated the appeals and revised the captions accordingly. Appeal No. 2026-1390 was not dismissed and remains subject to the court’s June 24, 2026 order. non-precedential non-precedential non-precedential

Key Points

  • The order is nonprecedential and addresses only voluntary dismissal procedure.
  • The appeal arose from PTAB IPR2024-00948, but the order does not identify the challenged patent, technology, or merits issues.
  • The parties jointly stipulated to dismiss Appeal No. 2026-1357 under FRAP 42(b), with each side bearing its own costs.
  • The Federal Circuit deconsolidated the appeals and revised the captions accordingly.
  • Appeal No. 2026-1390 was not dismissed and remains subject to the court’s June 24, 2026 order.
non-precedential

How this summary was made: Drafted with AI from the court's opinion or order. Read the document itself before relying on the summary. Editorial policy

More on this topic

New to Federal Circuit? See our Federal Circuit page